Tuesday, February 19, 2008

Just an "OUTLINE OF ARGUMENTS" on the motion that THBT Countries should boycott the 2008 Olympics in China due to human rights concerns

Background and Context of Debate:

Since China received in 2001 the honor to host the 2008 summer Olympics, one of the primary questions was whether it would be able to improve its human rights record to a level deemed appropriate by the international community for the purposes of hosting such an international event. Many believe that, as of 2007, it had failed to do so. In protest, many suggest that the most powerful tool that a country can level against China's alleged abuses, is a boycott of the 2008 Olympics. China, desiring very much to see its 2008 Olympics become a success, is fearful of such moves, and defensive against threats that move in this direction.

Pro

1. China failed to improve its human rights and is a boycott the right response. Repression in China has only gotten worse. Only boycotting the Olympics sufficiently protests China's abuses.

2. Is it acceptable to politicize the Olympics with boycotts. Politicizing and boycotting Beijing is necessary to uphold the Olympic spirit. The Olympic Charter states that "The goal of Olympism is to place sport at the service of the harmonious development of man, with a view to promoting a peaceful society concerned with the preservation of human dignity."

3. Olympic boycotts have been effective/desirable historically.

Con

1. China's 2008 Olympics will accelerate its civil society. Even if China's civil, democratic institutions and practices are not good currently, the Olympics is likely to help advance them into the future.

2. The Olympic games should not be politicized. Boycotting China will be against the spirit of the Olympics. The Olympic Charter clearly states that one of the missions of the Olympics is to "oppose any political or commercial abuse of sport and athletes". Boycotting China will go against this, as the athletes will lose one of their very few chances to compete in the Olympics, something they have worked towards for years, and taking away this well-deserved chance because of political discrepancies will fall under the "political abuse" of sports and athletes.

3. Olympic boycotts have achieved nothing historically. U.S. Olympic Committee Chiarman spokesman Darryl Seibel said, in reference to Olympic boycotts staged in 1956, 1976, 1980 and 1984, that, "as has been demonstrated in the past, boycotts accomplish absolutely nothing other than to unfairly penalize athletes who have spent decades preparing for that moment."

Sources:

Jonathan Zimmerman, Guest Columnist. "U.S. should boycott China's Olympics". Seattle PI. Friday, March 24, 2006.
Kevin B. Blackstone. "U.S. should boycott Beijing Olympics". Politico. June 18, 2007.
"Boycott 2008 Communist Olympics" - A blog dedicated to boycotting the 2008 Olympics
Gilad Nathan. "Boycott Beijing Olympics". Israel Opinion, YNetNews. August 11, 2007.
Nat Hentoff. "Nat Hentoff: Boycott 2008 China Olympics". April 17, 2007
Darren Ennis. "EU should boycott Beijing Olympics over Myanmar". Reuters. Thursday, September 27, 2007.
Lesh Donlup, a human rights volunteer in the UK. "10 reasons to boycott the 2008 Olympic Games in communist China". AZPlace. 13 September 2006
Reporters sans frontieres. "Beijing 2008". January 2008
Xinhua. "China says attempts to boycott Beijing Olympics doomed to fail". People's Daily Online. April 12, 2007
Nicholas D. Kristof. "More on Boycotting the Chinese Olympics." February 5, 2007
John J. Tkacik, Jr. "Beijing Olympics Boycott: A Wake-Up Call". The Heritage Foundation. August 22, 2007
"Olympic boycott calls 'will fail'". BBC News. Friday, May 18, 2007
Xujun Eberlein. "Beijing Olympic Boycott Over Burma Will Only Alienate Chinese People". New America Media. November 05, 2007
Eric Green, USINFO Staff Writer. "Views Mixed on Boycotting 2008 Beijing Olympics". US Consulate General Chengdu, China.

2 comments:

Jana said...

Well consider this then, If we dont stop the Genocide thats happening inside China to the peaceful Falun Gong who are having their organs forcibly taken from them resulting in obvious death to sell to the lucrative international transplant industry then we are no better than accomplices to this human rights disaster .

Hitler committed similar atrocities to the Jewish people and no one paid any attention then either and the Olympics went ahead and now we know the result.

Never Again is Happening Again.

Crimes Against Humanity and the Olympics cannot Co-exist

Please read the independent reports from 2 very distinguished Gentlemen in Canada at
http://organharvestinvestigation.net/

Shame and name the the Ccp .A boycott will work to save lives. Directly use their own human rights absues not Darfur and Sudan because most Chinese have no idea what Chinas involvment is in Darfur or Burma . Remember they have complete control over all Chinese media.

Arnel D. Mateo said...

We need to emphasize the value of human rights and to send the messege of how important it is to the international cxommunity. Crimes against humanitity shall not be tolerated.